Lord Rickard Karstark's death - General (ASoIaF) - Westeros
2008年8月16日 · So sending Karstark to the Wall would still have lost Robb the Karstarks with Rickard. It may not have made a difference with considerable parts of the Karstark foot who weren't at Riverrun at the time either, who may have preferred headhunting Jaime in any case. Besides, a great part of the Karstark foot was lost with Harrion Karstark at ...
General (ASoIaF) - A Forum of Ice and Fire - Westeros
2016年3月5日 · The five mistakes made by Robb Stark that are considered to be the most important in his downfall are: 1. Marrying Jeyne Westerling 2. Sending Theon Greyjoy as a emissary to the Iron Islands 3. Failure to punish his mother for treason 4. Decapitation of Lord Karstark 5. Failure to give precise or...
Why didn't Robb kill the Karstark men? - General (ASoIaF)
2016年2月4日 · When Karstark kills the Lannister captives, Robb orders his men executed and kills Karstark himself. However, when Ned makes his speech about doing the deed yourself, its after killing a Night's Watch deserter. Not a noble captive. There is no indication that there is a 'nobles obly' rule to the 'kill them yourself' rule
Lord Karstark and the Night's Watch. - General (ASoIaF) - A Forum …
2014年4月6日 · So I have a question for everyone who has read Storm of Swords/seen up to season 3 of Game of Thrones. Spoilers obviously.Robb's decision to execute Lord Karstark was one of the critical decisions that ultimately lead to his downfall, but was there another option. Instead of cutting off Rickard K...
Why doesn't House Stark have any cousins or Cadet Branches?
2014年9月4日 · Lord Rickard had no brothers but he had four children; Brandon - Died without an heir. Benjen - Took the black, no children. Lyanna - Dead, no children/one child. That leaves only Eddard who died with six children. Robb Stark - Died without a heir. Jon Snow - Took the black. Sansa, Arya, Bran and Rickon - Too young to have children.
Did Robb have to kill Karstark? - General (ASoIaF) - Westeros
2012年1月23日 · Karstark was basically a war criminal. Refusing to punish him would've made Robb either look weak (because people could assume he was afraid of a lesser lord) or dishonorable (because people could assume that Robb tacitly approved of Karstark's murder of prisoners) in the eyes of his bannermen.
Lord Karstark - E09: The Battle of the Bastards - A Forum of Ice and ...
2016年6月20日 · A Forum of Ice and Fire A Song of Ice and Fire & Game of Thrones
Why wasn't Rickard Karstark just sent to the Wall?
2015年2月17日 · In punishment, Robb beheaded Lord Karstark himself and had the other ten hung. Why wasn't Karstark just sent to the wall? I know he killed two children, but it is common practice for brutal criminals to be sent to the Nights Watch (Jon mentioned two of the apprentice boys being rapists, and Yoren was transporting two serial killers and a hitman ...
Karstark, Umber and Dreadfort - General (GoT) - Westeros
2016年6月21日 · Karstark ran, the fact that he wasn't fighting tells a lot. He'll try and negotiate terms of surrender although if Sansa and Jon pardon the House, Lord Karstark has to die. House Umber has to fall, they're responsible for Rickon's death. That can't be forgiven. They have to lose everything.The Dredfort Castellan doesn't go down fighting, why ...
Thenn/Karstark (spoilers) - General (ASoIaF) - A Forum of Ice and …
2012年7月23日 · On the other hand - Alys is (I think) the only remaining Karstark, other than Lord Harrion Karstark,mheld by the Lannisters, because Stannis will execute the Karstark betrayers. Would the Karstark soldiers, if freed, join Alys, or would the prospects of following a wildling repulse them, causing them to join someone else, presumably the Boltons.